top of page
  • Writer's pictureKate Taylor Design

Choosing the Best Coloring Tools: Pencils, Markers, or Crayons?

When you decide to embark on a coloring journey, one of the primary decisions you'll face is selecting the right tools. The question "Choosing the Best Coloring Tools: Pencils, Markers, or Crayons?" is one that every enthusiast grapples with. Each tool has its unique strengths and characteristics, offering different benefits and effects on paper.

Close-up of Colored Pencils
Close-up of Colored Pencils

Choosing the Best Coloring Tools: Pencils, Markers, or Crayons?

The allure of coloring isn't limited to just the pages and designs; it extends significantly to the tools one uses. Colored pencils, markers, and crayons represent the holy trinity of coloring instruments. Each tool possesses unique characteristics that can either enhance or change the coloring experience. So, let's delve into the nuanced world of coloring tools to help you decide which might be best suited for your creative endeavors.

Colored Pencils:

Arguably the most versatile among the trio, colored pencils offer an unparalleled precision. They're favored for the control they provide, especially when it comes to intricate designs and patterns commonly found in advanced coloring books.


  • Control: Pencils are perfect for tight spaces. Their pointed tips allow for precision, making them ideal for designs that have a lot of detail.

  • Blendability: Good quality colored pencils can be blended to create a gradient effect, which can lead to more depth and dimension in the artwork.

  • Shade Variation: By varying the pressure, you can lighten or darken the shade, giving you a range of hues from a single pencil.


  • Breakage: They can snap if dropped or if too much pressure is applied.

  • Regular Sharpening: To maintain precision, regular sharpening is needed which can lead to product wastage.


The marker's primary appeal is its ability to cover large areas quickly and evenly. When you're looking to fill vast expanses of space with vibrant and bold colors, markers are your best friends.


  • Uniformity: They provide even coverage without the variations in tone, making the colored area appear smooth.

  • Variety: Markers come in various tips - fine, broad, chisel, brush. This variety can cater to both detailing and filling.

  • Vibrancy: Typically, markers offer more vibrant colors compared to pencils and crayons.


  • Bleeding: They can bleed through the paper, especially if it's thin.

  • Drying Out: If not capped properly, they can dry out.


Crayons are the tools that introduce many of us to the world of coloring. They are robust, easy to handle, and come in a myriad of colors.


  • Durability: Unlike pencils, crayons don't easily snap. They can endure a lot of wear and tear.

  • Kid-Friendly: They're non-toxic and safe for children.

  • Texture: Crayons can create a beautiful textured appearance, giving the artwork a unique feel.


  • Less Precision: Due to their broader tips, it can be challenging to color intricate designs with crayons.

  • Wax Buildup: Layering can result in a waxy buildup which can affect the final look.

The Fusion Approach:

For many, sticking to just one tool isn't the norm. Combining different mediums can yield results that are unique and intriguing.

  • Pencils & Markers: Start by laying down a base with markers for uniformity and then add details or shading with pencils.

  • Pencils & Crayons: Use crayons for a textured background and then add details over it with pencils.

  • Markers & Crayons: Crayons can provide a textured backdrop, while markers can be used for detailed work or to add vibrancy.

Factors to Consider When Choosing:

  1. Skill Level: Beginners might find crayons or colored pencils easier to handle, while professionals might lean towards high-quality markers or pencils.

  2. Paper Quality: If you're using markers, ensure that the paper is thick enough to prevent bleed-through.

  3. Budget: Professional grade markers and colored pencils can be pricey. Determine a budget before diving into purchases.

  4. Purpose: If it's a casual hobby, crayons or basic colored pencils might suffice. However, if you're looking at creating art, investing in good quality markers and pencils might be a better option.

In conclusion, the journey of "Choosing the Best Coloring Tools: Pencils, Markers, or Crayons?" is deeply personal. It depends on your skill level, budget, and what you hope to achieve with your coloring. The world of coloring is vast and beautiful. The right tools can enhance this experience manifold, transforming it from a mere hobby to a therapeutic and fulfilling activity. So, take your time, experiment, and find the tools that resonate with your artistic soul.


bottom of page